Echosounders: Black Box vs Built-in

Published in Northwest Yachting Magazine - April 25, 2019

Marine electronics' manufacturers originally introduced a “black box” depth sounder to allow boaters with a basic chartplotter to add sounder “fish finder” functionality.  These external sounders turned a basic navigation screen into a multifunction display (MFD).  As fish finders grew in popularity, manufacturers began to include the sounder capability in the actual MFD.  As these all-in-one units became smaller and smaller, it allowed boaters with limited space to enjoy the benefits of a depth sounder without adding a sounder black box and integrating it with the chartplotter.  Today, larger boats still continue to use black boxes even though the installed multifunction display may already have a built-in sounder.  So what is the difference?  And which one is right for your boat?

Transducer.  As a quick refresher, a transducer emits a signal at certain frequencies into the water which is reflected off the bottom, underwater structures or fish.  This signal or echo is then received by the transducer and it is the sounder that translates all of the information from the transducer to the MFD so that we can actually see and understand the data.  There are a few intelligent or smart transducers on the market that are capable of converting simple echoes into depth readings however, the majority of today’s recreational transducers require a sounder, either built-in to the MFD or connected externally to display the information.

When computer manufacturers first introduced the all-in-one computer, consumers couldn't get enough.  You no longer had to have a huge computer tower under your desk with all the associated wires, it was replaced with one clean looking, all-inclusive screen.  A similar digital revolution happened in the marine electronics industry.  MFDs with a built-in sounder took up less space, required less equipment, did not require integration or a network and came with a much lower “plug and play” price tag.  For multiple display installs, the only downside was that if the screen with the built-in sounder failed, other displays connected to the display/sounder would lose the sounder capability as well.

External Sounder. As an alternative, boaters who do not want to put all their fish in one basket can still install an external sounder.  This black box is installed in a secure space that will not be submerged in water, is adequately ventilated and not exposed to extreme temperatures.  It is also a good idea to put it somewhere that you can easily see the LED lights for trouble-shooting.  It requires power and you will have to run the transducer cable to the unit as well as a cable to the chartplotter or MFD.  Because these external sounders are so feature-rich, many boaters terminate the transducer cable to a network cable to make the data available to multiple displays throughout the boat.

Larger boat owners also use an external or black box sounder because they have screens that are over 16".  Most manufacturers have built in sounders up to and including the 16" model.  After that, models such as the 17", 22" and 24" MFDs do not have a sounder built in thus keeping down the size and weight of the unit.

Built-in sounder modules will support up to a 1kW transducer and are of the same quality and effectiveness as an external version of the same. This will allow up to, a theoretical, 5,000 feet depth capability paired with the right transducer. This basically covers the mass majority of marine electronics users, both pleasure boaters as well as most fishing boats, while keeping the electronics at a lower price point.  Some offshore commercial fishing boats require a sounder module that is capable of supporting up to a 3kW transducer allowing greater depth capabilities up to 10,000 feet.  These sounders are available at a greater cost.

Once installed, both an external black box sounder or a built-in sounder provide unprecedented shallow target resolution or deep water terrain and bottom tracking.  Many spread spectrum or CHIRP sounders scan on multiple frequencies, allowing you to track the bottom in deep water with the low chirp (50 kHz) or fish in shallow water with the high chirp (200 kHz). 

Transducer Adapters. The newer black box sounders use an 8 or 12 pin transducer connection.  Manufacturers, like Garmin, offer a transducer adapter box which allows you to compensate from 6 to 8 pin or 8 to 12 pin. There are also wire block adapters if you have to modify the end of your transducer cable to fit the sounder module.    In some cases you can simply use your existing transducer, with no need for a haul-out, saving time and money. Sounder black boxes even allow you to connect multiple transducers at the same time to view different depths, and side-view.  This allows you the ability to enhance your existing screen.

An MFD with a built-in sounder is great for boats with limited mounting space and costs less than buying the modules separately however if there is a failure, you have to replace the whole unit.  An external sounder is required for larger screens, offers advanced integration and is more expensive but if there is a failure it is just a matter of replacing the sounder or the MFD.  Any route you choose, adding an updated sounder to your boat, either a built-in or black box, provides an almost video quality picture of what is happening under your boat.


About the author: Jeff Cote is a systems design engineer and owner of Pacific Yacht Systems, a full service shop delivering marine electrical and navigation solutions for recreational boats. Visit their website and blog for info and articles on marine electrical systems, projects and more: www.pysystems.ca.

 

Related Content